Bowen: US-Iran deal raises inescapable question of what the war was for

Key developments are emerging from the global stage. Bowen: US-Iran deal raises inescapable question of what the war was for21 minutes ago Share Save Add as preferred on GoogleJeremy BowenInternational editorAFP via Getty ImagesIranian civilians have been living under the threat of strikes for monthsThe memorandum of understanding signed by President Donald Trump and President Masoud Pezeshkian of Iran lays out the political, military and economic consequences of the ill-judged decision to attack Iran on 28 February. The human cost is already clear. Thousands have been killed, many of them civilians, in Iran and Lebanon.

The US, and by extension Israel, have suffered a strategic defeat. The regime in Tehran faced its worst nightmare: a joint military operation to cripple or destroy it by the US, the world's strongest power, and Israel, the Middle East's superpower. The regime has not just survived.

The Details

It has been empowered. Its strategy of blocking the Strait of Hormuz, and with it one fifth of the world's supplies of oil and gas as well as other vital components in the global economy, has forced Trump to agree to a series of concessions that have infuriated and alarmed America's Iran hawks and the Israeli government. The memorandum of understanding - or MOU - calls for an end to the war in Lebanon.

Israel says that cannot happen. It wants a free hand in Lebanon, and that issue has the capacity to cause an even sharper rift between Israel and the US, and play into the hands of Iranian hardliners who oppose any deal with the Americans. In return for reopening the Strait, the MOU's language says the US will lift its counter blockade of Iranian ports, waive sanctions allowing Iran to earn billions of dollars from exporting oil and start the process of returning billions more to Iran by unfreezing assets that it held abroad.

That is before they get down to the hard business of negotiating a nuclear deal. It is the price of returning to the way they were on 27 February, the day before the US and Israel launched the war. On that day the Strait of Hormuz was open for shipping and American and Iranian negotiators were discussing a nuclear deal.

What Experts Say

The signing of the MOU means that the negotiators will go back to work and ships will be able to transit the Strait of Hormuz. Moment Trump signs Iran deal at Palace of VersaillesJoe Biden's Secretary of State, Antony Blinken, posted on X "the only 'achievement' of the ceasefire is the likely reopening of the Strait of Hormuz – which was open before the war started. And we will apparently pay Iran to do so.

"The question of what exactly the war was for is inescapable and will not go away. It amounts to Trump's worst foreign policy blunder so far. It might also spell the end of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's long political career.

The development has drawn wide international attention, with diplomatic circles watching closely.